We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post. This helps support what we do and in no way costs you a thing.
I had always heard people fondly mention Shipshewana—a place where time slows down, and the Amish way of life thrives in simplicity and tradition. When I finally had the chance to visit this gem in northern Indiana, I quickly understood why this small town is so beloved. Nestled in LaGrange County, Shipshewana is part of the third-largest of the Amish communities in the United States, home to around 14,000 Amish residents. Though the town itself may be small, with a population of just over 700, it serves as a vibrant hub for both the local Amish community and visitors seeking an authentic experience in Indiana’s Amish Country.
Coming from Wisconsin, I’m no stranger to Amish farms and the familiar sight of Amish buggies traveling down our country roads. We have a wonderful Amish community that brings a touch of tradition to rural life, and it’s not unusual to see families working in the fields or driving their horse-drawn buggies.
However, unlike Shipshewana, we don’t have a centralized Amish town with dedicated stores and attractions. Visiting Shipshewana, where the entire town is steeped in Amish culture, was a completely different experience—one that immersed me in the heart of an Amish lifestyle in a way I hadn’t encountered before.
Driving into Shipshewana, I fully expected to pass an Amish buggy or two along the way. What I didn’t expect was to see Amish children out on a bike ride, or women pedaling along on three-wheel Amish bikes. And then, to my surprise, I spotted an Amish couple on a recumbent bike! These were certainly not the typical Amish experiences I had anticipated observing, but they offered a delightful glimpse into the unique blend of tradition and modernity present in this community.
Shipshewana may be a small town, but it offers a wealth of things to do that goes far beyond the usual Amish attractions. From bustling flea markets to hands-on workshops and delicious home-cooked meals, the variety of activities is truly impressive. While there’s so much to explore,
I’m going to focus on just 11 highlights that will give you a true taste of Amish culture and the unique charm of this special town. Whether you’re visiting for the first time or returning to discover more, these experiences capture the heart and soul of Shipshewana.
1. Shipshewana Flea Market
As the Midwest’s largest flea market, the Shipshewana Flea Market is a must-visit for anyone seeking a truly unique shopping experience. With over 700 booths, it’s nearly impossible to walk out of there empty-handed. Whether you’re browsing for food, handmade crafts, antiques, or those quirky finds you never knew you needed, there’s something for everyone. The market is a treasure trove of random goods, and there’s something new to see around every corner—even beautiful murals that add a touch of art to the bustling atmosphere.
On my visit, I was specifically on the hunt for two legendary items: the ever-popular “Happy Salt” and the amusingly named BARF Jam. Both proved to be well worth the search, and I left the market with a few other unexpected finds as well. While on my mission to find the legendary “BARF Jam” at the Shipshewana Flea Market, I wasn’t entirely sure which of the Amish stores carried it, so naturally, I started asking around. Each vendor seemed more perplexed than the last.
One woman, however, topped them all—she pulled a horrified face that could only be described as a mix of disbelief and utter disgust. “We would NEVER make anything like that!” she gasped, looking at me as if I’d suggested something truly scandalous. Her reaction was so priceless, that I had to stifle a laugh.
After several more puzzled expressions, I finally found the booth I was looking for, only to realize that I had misheard the name entirely—it was actually “BARN Jam.” Though slightly disappointed, I couldn’t help but laugh again when I spotted something else on the table: “BARF Salsa.” At least I wasn’t completely off!
As for the elusive “Happy Salt,” this seasoning had been touted as a miracle spice—something that could elevate just about any dish. I had heard it described as a blend of salt, garlic, onion, and other spices that worked wonders on everything from meats and vegetables to popcorn and scrambled eggs. The buzz around it suggested it was the kind of seasoning that every kitchen should have, a go-to for adding that perfect touch of flavor to any meal. After finally tracking it down, I couldn’t wait to test its powers at home and see if it lived up to its legendary status.
It did.
Pro Tips: Take cash, get an early start, and give yourself plenty of time. I think at least 4 hours.
2. Cooks Bison Ranch
For a truly unique experience, visit Cooks Bison Ranch, a 700-acre working bison ranch that’s home to about 400 head of the great American Bison. Your adventure starts with a hay-wagon ride into the pasture, led by a local expert guide who will teach you all about the intricacies of raising, feeding, and managing these majestic animals.
This hour-long tour is an experience for all ages, offering you the chance to hand-feed bison right in their natural habitat. Now, I am not saying that I got one to kiss me — but you can check out their Facebook page to see the video for yourself.
Now bison and buffalo are different species; bison (like the American bison) have a large hump and are found in North America, while buffalo (such as the African buffalo and water buffalo) lack the hump and are primarily found in Africa and Asia. They also differ in behavior, habitat, and cultural significance.
Um, and taste.
Afterward, you can savor the taste of tender, healthy bison meat with a meal featuring either a Bison Burger or a classic chuck-wagon BBQ. This is what I like to call a “meet and eat” tour—where you gain a deeper appreciation for where your food comes from while enjoying the delicious flavors that come with it. If you’re planning a group visit, consider adding a meal to extend your time to two hours, and don’t forget to check out the gift shop for bison-related goodies. I got a cool T-shirt and bison stuffy!
3. E & S Sales
E&S Sales is more than just a bulk food store—it’s a place where you can see Amish craftsmanship and food production in action in downtown Shipshewana. During our visit, we were lucky enough to get a behind-the-scenes tour where we watched everything from pizza making to pasta packaging and even the creation of delicious whoopie pies!
This store is known for its fabulous prices, which makes it the best place to stock up on Amish soup mixes, fresh baked goods, and other local favorites. Trust me when I say, you’ll want to bring a cooler with you—there are just too many bargains to pass up. Fill your cart with everything from pantry staples to fresh produce to sweet treats, and enjoy a little taste of Amish Country at home.
4. Amish Home Dining Experience
If you’re looking for a true taste of Amish hospitality, the Amish Home Dining Experience is a must. Picture this: multiple courses, two different kinds of meat, an incredible selection of side dishes (including tender Amish chicken and hearty noodles), and, of course, a selection of homemade pies for dessert.
It’s the kind of meal that warms your soul, full of rich flavors and traditional recipes passed down through generations. What could be better than sitting down to a home-cooked meal, surrounded by the simple beauty of an Amish home, and enjoying the kind of food that makes you feel like part of the family?
5. Blue Gate Restaurant
A visit to Blue Gate Restaurant is more than just a meal—it’s a full experience. Start by exploring their fabulous gift shop, which offers a wide selection of unique items to browse before or after you eat. Once you’ve worked up an appetite, dive into their large buffet filled with comforting, home-cooked Amish dishes that will leave you fully satisfied.
And if you’ve ever heard of “Shipshe pie,” it’s likely from someone who’s been to the Blue Gate. Their incredible varieties of pie is legendary—from classic apple to rich chocolate cream—making them the perfect ending to any meal. I was a fan of the local favorite: “finger pie”.For locals and visitors alike, Blue Gate’s pies are a sweet tradition you don’t want to miss!
6. Menno-Hof Museum
To truly deepen your understanding of Amish culture and Mennonite communities, a visit to the Menno-Hof Museum is essential. This engaging museum offers an immersive experience, showcasing the history, beliefs, and lifestyle of these groups through interactive displays and a guided tour.
As a Lutheran myself, I was surprised to discover just how similar our roots are—an unexpected connection that left me with a newfound appreciation for the Amish way of life. While you’re there, don’t miss the chance to admire the beautiful quilts on display, each one a stunning example of Amish craftsmanship.
7. Making Pretzels at Ben’s Pretzels
Who knew that an Amish-founded business could grow into a national chain? And yes, there is an actual Ben behind it all! Beyond making your own pretzel, you can indulge in a variety of delicious options, from stuffed pretzels to an assortment of dips, all ready to be enjoyed on the spot.
If you are with a group try a hands-on experience: making pretzels yourself. Not only will you learn the art of pretzel-making from start to finish, but you’ll also get to enjoy your freshly baked creation afterward. The experience doesn’t have to end there, though. Ben’s also offers a boxed mix so you can recreate that great-tasting treat at home—perfect for impressing friends and family with your newfound pretzel-making skills!
8. Catch a Show at the Blue Gate Theatre
One of the most surprising and impressive experiences in Shipshewana is catching a show at the Blue Gate Theatre. I was amazed to learn that the theater had acquired the rights to many Amish books and had turned them into stage productions. After the debut at the Blue Gate, these shows are leased to theaters across the nation—an innovative and enterprising approach to bringing Amish stories to life.
I saw Josiah for President, and it was so well done that I was moved to tears. The performances are heartfelt and genuine, making the Blue Gate Theatre a must-visit for anyone wanting to experience Amish culture through the arts.
9. Davis Mercantile
For a unique shopping experience, make your way to the Davis Mercantile. This historic building is home to a variety of small specialty shops, each offering something special. One of my favorite finds was at the Olympia Candy Kitchen, where I scored a jar of Amish Peanut Butter. Imagine peanut butter blended with marshmallow fluff—it sounds unconventional, but don’t knock it until you try it!
Beyond great things like treats, the mercantile is filled with whimsical decor and an impressive variety of fabrics for quilting projects, making it a fun spot to explore. And don’t miss a ride on the vintage carousel—this beautifully restored gem adds a touch of nostalgia to your visit, offering a delightful experience for visitors of all ages.
10. Making a Basket or Amish Doll
What could be better than a souvenir that you made yourself? Engage your creative side by participating in a workshop where you’ll learn from Amish craftsmen about the art of making traditional baskets or dolls. Along with the fun of crafting, you’ll gain an insider’s look into the culture behind these time-honored skills.
These hands-on experiences provide more than just a beautiful handmade souvenir—they offer a deeper connection to Amish traditions and a memorable way to take a piece of Shipshewana home with you!
11. Get Ice Cream
If you’ve got a sweet tooth, you won’t want to miss out on the ice cream in Shipshewana. Vanilla Bean is a local favorite, offering a delightful twist on dessert with their ice cream flights. It’s the perfect way to sample several delicious flavors at once—because why settle for just one when you can try them all?
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re exploring the scenic drives of Elkhart County or taking a short trip through Northwest Indiana, a visit to Shipshewana in the heart of Indiana Amish Country offers an unforgettable experience. This is a great place to embrace the slower pace of Amish life, breathe in the fresh air, and connect with Amish families and their traditions.
From savoring cinnamon caramel donuts and local cuisine at an Amish restaurant to perusing small shops along Main Street, there’s something for everyone here. You’ll discover that modern amenities blend seamlessly with old-world charm, offering both live entertainment and hands-on activities like making baskets and pretzels.
Shipshewana is more than just a destination—it’s a journey into a culture where family, faith, and craftsmanship take center stage. Whether it’s your first time or you’re a seasoned visitor, Indiana Amish Country offers a fresh perspective with each trip. So, take a scenic drive, relax in the surrounding area, and enjoy the best of Amish people and their rich heritage. It’s all waiting for you in the heart of Indiana and I can’t wait to go back.
FAQs
1. What is the best time to visit Shipshewana?
The best time to visit Shipshewana is during the warmer months, typically from May to October. This is when the famous flea market is open, and many of the outdoor attractions, including Cooks Bison Ranch, are in full swing.
2. Is Shipshewana a family-friendly destination?
Absolutely! Shipshewana offers a wide range of family-friendly activities, from hands-on workshops like pretzel making and crafting Amish dolls to scenic drives and animal encounters at Cooks Bison Ranch. There’s something for every age to enjoy.
3. Do Amish people run the businesses in Shipshewana?
Yes, many businesses in Shipshewana are Amish-owned and operated, including food stores, workshops, and farms. You’ll get an authentic glimpse into Amish culture and traditions by visiting these establishments.
4. Can I buy Amish-made goods in Shipshewana?
Yes, Shipshewana is home to numerous Amish shops offering handmade crafts, furniture, baked goods, and local specialties. The Davis Mercantile, E&S Sales, and the flea market are excellent places to find authentic Amish products.
